Our understanding of how diversity originates in animal communication is heavily dependent on adaptive explanations. Yet the initial trigger of signal diversification need not be direct selection on signal design, but a by-product of genetic differentiation between populations. Using a population-level phylogenetic approach, we can examine whether: 1) signal divergence occurs between populations when animals communicate in different environments (divergence is adaptive); or 2) geographic variation in communication is explained by the degree populations are genetically distinct (divergence is 'neutral'). Playback experiments are then used to test whether, irrespective of its initial cause, divergences in communication facilitate reproductive isolation, with its obvious implications for speciation.
Eastern water dragons offer an ideal species to study these sorts of questions. |